Yesterday while I was thinking
about how inconvenient it is to travel in a crowded train in a hot and humid
climate... a lady with 2 girls of age about 2 & 6 boarded the train and
started chanting a bhajan. The younger girl looked ashen and was half asleep in
lady’s arms and the elder one went from person to person begging and then when
refused...even touching their feet..!!! By the time the girl came to me I got a
call...and frankly...I was relieved that now I can pretend to be busy on call
and that would definitely help me avoid the little one!
The caller ID displayed +91140xxxxxx...I
could easily make out that this is some junk call...still...seeing the need
of the hour I answered it...
Me: Hello
Caller: Sir, I am Shweta calling from XYZ Organization. We are basically a NGO working for children welfare... (If I was a person who read a lot of conspiracy stories...I would have been easily convinced that this is another conspiracy where “they” first send in little children in trains for begging and then call people in the train for donations!! Definitely a method with quite high efficiency!)
The NGO sure is doing some good
work trying to help out children like these little girls...but very presence of
these girls in front of my eyes depicted that the number of NGOs and the
donations they get are quite few compared to the number of children who need
such organizations! What about the rest of children? How are they supposed to survive?
The only options that such children have (according
to me) are:
Go toBeing sent to some NGO or child care/ foster care homes- Work in some place (tea stalls, small hotels, etc)
- Get involved in activities like stealing, pick pocketing, etc
- Beg!!
Leave apart a few NGOs who
maintain high standards of transparency, we are quite aware of (thanks to Indian
media and movies) malpractices involved in various foster homes, the miserable
living conditions at such places! Sometimes the torture is so much that the
child considers living on the streets without any food as a better option and flees
away from the foster home!
So much for the best option available...
So much for the best option available...
Whenever we see any adult
begging...who might look capable enough...Our reaction is “why can’t he work if
he is alright!!” ...but what about children? The Government of India has been
proactive on this...and banned Child Labour! Various laws have been passed
against people involved with child labour! Thus, getting a job is itself a
difficult task for a small kid and moreover as it is illegal...one can easily
imagine the working conditions in which a child will have to work if he/she
gets a job somewhere!!
Coming to the third option...should we?? Offcourse...Afterall people who are well educated and mature are sometimes unable to figure out
what’s right and what’s wrong...then how can a small child be expected to judge
the difference between good and bad? They just follow some of the "elders" who pretend to (or maybe they actually do) understand them. The elders who don't have to work hard...who get to eat whenever they are hungry..who have a place to stay and all sorts of new new things!! But we do know that for most of them...this would be a one way street!!
Fourth option?? This is where a child lands up after rejecting or being rejected by first three options!! But again...this is not we want for the children of our country!!
To think of it...all this time we have been talking about "survival options", leave apart studies or anything else... and still apart from the
first, all other options available to such unfortunate children are
illegal! And as discussed...first option is not much of a choice after all!!
So the options a kid has are either illegal or miserable!
Now if someone says... “That’s
why we should support NGOs like CRY, etc” or “Only we citizens together can
make this to change”...then I would like to ask..Is this a feasible and
complete solution? Among us how many are aware or I guess it’s better to
ask...how many are concerned about this problem!!?? And even if concerned...then
how many are willing or able to donate?
Also...level of awareness about such
issues among people can be judged by the fact that still in this country
election results are more dependent on the alms being distributed by
politicians just before election rather than the background of contesting
person or party or even their manifesto!!!
At individual level: I can’t
think of anything more than donating to NGO once in a while (with a limitation
imposed by my pocket). At organization (NGO) level: There again is limitation
of funds and the gap between children receiving help & requiring help is
HUGE!!! At government level: Am not sure of what is being done or frankly... I
don’t have much clue of what can be done!!
But again people in
administrative positions are not bunch of illiterates but highly qualified IAS
officers, sociologists, economists etc., who have much better understanding of
such issues and I believe, they can definitely find some better options for
these kids if they try to!
I hope...a few years later...I need not answer a junk call, just to avoid some little girl...
nice but baffled thinking on the domain.. couldn't stop myself from commenting on this post of yours. you spoke of laws, but are they followed??? if you ever get an opportunity to visit any 'Sarkari' office, you'd find a kid age group 10-13 years getting tea for the karamcharis; no one will object to it..
ReplyDeleteSecondly, a huge ballyhoo was created in 2012, when free primary education was made available, it still exists; but then there are choices made by the poor too..
I know and have done, carried a few children in my car to get them enrolled in schools so that they can get free education and food, they won't last there more than a week (max). This is the magic of 'free/effortless money' they get of begging..
You said, the best you could do was alms to NGOs, don't you think donating time is much more valuable than donating money!! there are initiatives like bharat calling which actually make our time count..
Never the less, nice read!!!
totally agreed to your point..
Deletebut the issue concerning me here is whether the NGOs in themselves are capable of dealing with the whole problem!!??
and as far as sarkari office thing is concerned...somehow i feel...for kids who dont get NGP support...this is actually the best option...atleast thr r some kids who in tht small age make up their minds to be incharge of their own future...and such employment opportunities give them a chance to make their dreams come true..!!
Me agree with Khyati's opinion, time is more valuable specially when it is India. Nobody knows where the money is going, mostly it is not going in the right hands. NGOs are more like a business for many people (most of them are either political, rich or criminal) who have Jugaad(approach) in govt. office to get the NGO registered and start getting aid (free money) in the name of social-service, which also provide some relaxation in the tax while at the same time one can turn his/her black money in to white by showing it as the donation money and make a huge capital from that.
ReplyDeleteTherefore, if one can give the time not money or monitor the use of his/her own money in front of his/her own eyes by being physically present in the NGO then that would be the best thing.
Somehow, allowing a kid to work as regular can't be justified with any argument while working on the parental art to save the culture seems fine.
Kids are supposed to eat, play, study and learn.
Valuable thoughts, thanks for sharing !!!
sure sir...ideally thats what kids are supposed to do...but then all are not lucky...and then if we devote our time to NGOs...then what about the kids who are not enrolled with NGOs..whats their fault???
Deleteenlightening :)
ReplyDeletethe first thing that struck my mind was....wo 0140xxxxx se mujhe bhi roz phone ata hai ...hehehe
why did u avoid her? Coz Man is a 'cognitive Miser'...thats how everybody is ..
Secondly, their mind is so indoctrinated that if they are put to school, they do not study. Ye log sab mid-day meals khane jaate hain...
We need to channelise their psyche alongwith the objectives of the NGOs
cognitive miser!! :O
Deletei dnt even knw wat it is!! :P
anyways u r right about channelising!
but how!!??